diff --git a/.project/history/20260628_grok-work-review-02.md b/.project/history/20260628_grok-work-review-02.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..515f31d3 --- /dev/null +++ b/.project/history/20260628_grok-work-review-02.md @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +# Grok Work Review — Cycle 02 (2026-06-28T17:54Z) + +Recurring 30-min review of Grok-authored work, per owner instruction. + +## Scope reviewed +- **New committed Grok work since cycle 01 (`93d7fd16`):** none. +- **In-flight (uncommitted) Grok work:** a new `mc-sim` declarative scenario-runner — + `src/simulator/crates/mc-sim/src/bin/sim_scenario.rs` (+ `[[bin]]` decl), scenario data under + `public/games/age-of-dwarves/data/sim-scenarios/` (`smoke_duel_30t.json`, + `game1_headless_systems_150t.json`, `combat/`), and doc wiring (AGENTS.md §2.1 now names + `sim_scenario` as the preferred statistical sim-proof primitive; `scripts/run/dist.sh`, + `simulator-infra.md`, `agents-task-map.md`, `finish-game-1/SKILL.md`). + +## Independent verification + +| Check | Result | Notes | +|-------|--------|-------| +| `cargo check -p mc-sim --bin sim_scenario` | ✅ 0 errors (1 doc warn) | Grok's in-flight harness compiles | +| `cargo test -p mc-player-api` (cycle-01 open gate) | ✅ 142 lib + 42 integ = **184 / 0 failed** | lib count **142** matches Grok's `eca713bf` claim exactly | + +### Note on a measurement race (reviewer error, not Grok's) +A first hurried `mc-player-api` run appeared to show only "1 passed". That was a wait-loop that +exited on the first (fast lib) result line before the integration binaries ran — re-running cleanly +gave the full 184/0. Recorded here for honesty; no defect in Grok's work. + +## Assessment of the in-flight scenario harness +Design is sound: declarative JSON scenario (map/players/rules/metrics/assertions), seeded multi-run, +machine-readable BatchResult, intended for horizontal fan-out on the DO fleet after `dist:publish`. +Aligns with Rail-1 (drives `mc-turn::TurnProcessor` + worldsim pre-pass + mc-ai personalities; no +new sim logic in GDScript) and Rail-2 (scenarios are JSON content). It is **not yet committed** — so +per AGENTS.md §2 it is correctly *not* claimed done anywhere; no objective should flip on it until +Grok commits + cites a fleet run artifact. + +## Objective-status impact +None. No committed status changes since cycle 01; in-flight work is correctly un-closed. Dashboard +unchanged (305 done / 0 partial / 0 stub / 2 missing stretch / 31 oos). The cycle-01 open +verification gate (mc-player-api) is now **reproduced green**. + +## Next cycle +Watch for Grok to commit the `sim_scenario` harness — when it lands, verify it builds in the closing +commit (not a follow-up fix), run a scenario locally, and confirm the cited fleet artifact exists. +GUT headless 608/0 still un-reproduced (needs Godot headless) — attempt next cycle if a display path +is available.